Go for Grim Reaper for sure.
Also, could you change his skin to the one on the sin's? Would look more like the Reaper if he had it (: Not sure about others, havent been around quite a while. Perhaps Mages, the game lacks of them. And some good statistic WARRIOR (not agi hero) that would actually dish out very big numbers pretty often. PR shouldnt be the only DPS out there..
Thanks (:
Oh, btw, could you make the middle town safe from sins? Would be more lovely if you wouldnt die every night.